×

Loading...
Ad by
  • 予人玫瑰,手有余香:加拿大新天地工作移民诚聘求职顾问&行业导师!
Ad by
  • 予人玫瑰,手有余香:加拿大新天地工作移民诚聘求职顾问&行业导师!

引一段话,老迷和反勃派请进。

没有理由的引用,就是想让你们知道,你们倒勃的理由很荒谬。

“Is there anyone who can resist that glorious tune that opens and then dominates the first movement of the Op. 88 Quintet? OK, maybe Brahms repeats it a time or two too often in that long movement, but I for one never tire of it. Surely it is one of his happiest creations. The Leipzigers play it and the succeeding three movements with plenty of juice, just the way I like my Brahms. I despair when people say Brahms is an 'academic' or 'dry' composer whose use of old, classic forms is a throwback. (Are there really any people left who feel they have to diss Brahms in order to support Wagner?) These quintets certainly put the lie to that canard. This is hugely expressive music that, nonetheless, is best suited for the intimacy of a chamber music setting, not an orchestra. Brahms knew what he was doing. ”
Report

Replies, comments and Discussions:

  • 枫下拾英 / 乐韵书香 / 引一段话,老迷和反勃派请进。
    没有理由的引用,就是想让你们知道,你们倒勃的理由很荒谬。

    “Is there anyone who can resist that glorious tune that opens and then dominates the first movement of the Op. 88 Quintet? OK, maybe Brahms repeats it a time or two too often in that long movement, but I for one never tire of it. Surely it is one of his happiest creations. The Leipzigers play it and the succeeding three movements with plenty of juice, just the way I like my Brahms. I despair when people say Brahms is an 'academic' or 'dry' composer whose use of old, classic forms is a throwback. (Are there really any people left who feel they have to diss Brahms in order to support Wagner?) These quintets certainly put the lie to that canard. This is hugely expressive music that, nonetheless, is best suited for the intimacy of a chamber music setting, not an orchestra. Brahms knew what he was doing. ”
    • 反勃派已经丢盔弃甲了。。。
      • 老迷忙,而且他保证了三个月不说博拉姆斯,他们这是趁火打劫
      • 我对老迷深表同情,我刚才把潭里所有的关于老勃的辩论都粗粗看了一下,老迷是遍体鳞伤呀
    • 关于勃拉姆斯,我来写个提纲,反正也是臭了,就臭到底吧。
      • 1.我们现在的讨论标准是什么?我们是在用贝多芬,莫扎特,和巴赫的标准来要求他,所以不要走远了,他再差,也是一个80分(A和C之间), 这是个前提。
        • 他再好,也是一个80分
      • 两种艺术观,为艺术而艺术还是为生活和思想而艺术?为什么提这个,我觉得这在评价老勃时很重要,就是我们通常说的主题性吧。
      • 老勃的作品的局限性在哪里?这种问题是无解的? 包括楼主自己也说过,音乐评论是最扯蛋的,但我们是否还是该思考一下呢?
      • wuhuwuhu 要睁大wo de 眼睛 - - - - -
    • Citation without source just like trick, I won't waste my brick unless I have my target!。。。